Murphy’s. Caffrey’s. Haggerty’s. Yes, even the Harp and Shamrock. Besides being area drinking establishments frequented by Marquette students, these bars share another more sinister characteristic.
An exclusive months-long investigation by The Warrior suggests that all these businesses have names with Irish roots and collude to keep out competitors with more culturally inclusive atmospheres. Although most students remain oblivious to this implicit privileging of Irishness over other ethnicities, some have begun to question the status quo and their role in perpetuating Irish cultural domination, although they would speak to The Warrior only on the condition of anonymity.
For these dissidents, their heightened consciousness seems to stem from the festivities associated with St. Patrick’s Day. This day arguably commemorates the patron saint of Ireland who battled snakes as he spread Christianity throughout the Emerald Isle in the fifth century, but it has become a much-beloved occasion for parades, parties, and especially drinking. As one student put it, though, “When I was on campus celebrating St. Patty’s Day because I had nowhere else to go for spring break, I suddenly felt convicted of the insidious nature of this holiday. Here I was in an Irish-sounding bar surrounded by people wearing green, pretending to blend in, to ‘be Irish’ as it were. But I’m not. I’m mostly Bulgarian with some Liechtensteiner blood. I felt the ancestors shaking their heads in disgust.”
This assumption of universal Irishness, implicit in the bar names and St. Patrick’s Day, harms those who come from other backgrounds. In describing the psychological effects of this, a student of Czech ancestry observed, “It’s not that I need to have my Czechness affirmed every Thursday night or anything like that, or need a bar called Svoboda’s, but the total absence of my heritage within Marquette’s drinking culture hurts. I will always remember the scorn and almost disgust expressed by a bartender at one in the morning one time when I suggested major celebrations for St. Wenceslas Day [September 28, patron saint of the Czechs].” Given the number of national heritages represented at Marquette, it does seem striking that only Irishness is so privileged.
Of course, the obvious counterargument stresses the proud Irish Catholic heritage of many, perhaps even most, Marquette students and views the Irish struggle for freedom from Britain and the Irish-American battle for equal treatment in America as inspiring examples for us all. Perhaps, according the pro-Irish faction, we’re all Irish now.
Yet those who favor diversity with their drink refuse to buy into Marquette’s universal Irishness. “Just because we applied to Notre Dame as our first choice school and wear green to avoid getting physically assaulted on March 17 does not make us Irish,” complained one frequent patron of Marquette’s Irish bars, a graduate student with some Japanese and Texan heritage. Those who come from cultures without their own patron saints or religious traditions which reject specific saints describe an even starker reality. “Even if the bars opened their doors to modernity and inclusion by celebrating every patron saint’s day, I would still be left out because I am an atheist,” one student said while furtively glancing around.
These underground activists against the Irishness of our world seem unsure of their next step in what promises to be a long and painful battle for the soul of the Marquette community. Yet they remain determined to resist the Irish dominance underlying the area’s night life. As the first student quoted above remarked, “I don’t know how to rectify this injustice, but mark my words. It’s going down on October 19, St. John of Rila’s Day [commemorating patron saint of Bulgaria]. Bulgarians of Marquette, unite!”
Oddly enough, neither he nor any other student interviewed for this piece proposed a boycott of the campus bar scene, and they were eager to distance themselves from any suggestion of this and put down those groups which abstain from alcohol. This exclusion of certain groups from the inclusion campaign itself perhaps shows just how difficult Marquette’s long walk to freedom will be. As the graduate student put it, “Do I look Amish, Mormon, or Muslim to you?” No, indeed, he did not.
**DISCLAIMER – This article is apart of The Warrior’s April Fool’s Edition
Popularity: 1% [?]







