Of course, pizzas, burgers and subs are staples for a college student’s nutritional regime (or lack thereof). But the unsung hero of college dining would definitely be the buffalo chicken wing. Everyone’s favorite utensil-free food with built-in humility is always a good experience to be shared, despite the mess factor. Whether it’s one of the several wing choices around campus, or one of the great options further out, buffalo chicken wings are definitely worth the trip by bus or car.
Therefore, some members of the Warrior staff went “hunting” for the best buffalo chicken wings within a 15-mile radius of Marquette University. We’ve attempted to unscientifically provide college students with the best bang for their proverbial buck. Each location is accessible by bus, with the last being available by L.I.M.O., and each establishment was evaluated on the size, cost/value, variety and taste of their chicken wings, in addition to the atmosphere and “fun factor” at each locale. Finally, any novelties or interesting items on each menu were noted and the group picked our “clubhouse favorite” flavor of chicken wing after each tasting. While the Warriors involved might now claim extensive knowledge of chicken wings, it should be noted that none of our digestives systems were hearty enough to handle extremely spicy or hot wings so we invite our readers to further our research into this area at their leisure.
Hooters
No buffalo wing lover could exclude Hooters from the list of must-have wings. With 435 locations in 46 states and 20 countries, Hooters has been putting their spin on wings since 1983. While they aren’t often considered a “family establishment,” there were families enjoying the many food options the night we went hunting.
The closest Hooters to Marquette is at 7700 W. Layton Ave. in Greenfield, which isn’t too far for the Hooters experience. The atmosphere is as described on their menus: “delightfully tacky, yet unrefined.” With seven sauces ranging from Mild to 911 Hot, the diversity of wings isn’t as extensive as the other places. Interestingly, the wings are breaded and then fried. However, the general consensus was that while the wings were a little greasy, they were pretty flavorful. As long as you don’t order the “mild,” which according to our waitress Marie, doesn’t have much flavor, the wings were quite the meal. Hooters was the only establishment to feature full chicken wings – unseparated drummets and wings – and as an unconventional twist, you could order 20 wings and a bottle of champagne as a meal.
After sampling the Medium, Hot, Cajun and Samurai (teriyaki) varieties, the group voted that the clubhouse favorite was the Cajun because of its interesting combination of tangy flavors. The menu also featured various seafood and sandwiches, but the most interesting thing would have to be the fried pickles appetizer. In all, Hooters scored high in the atmosphere and fun factors. But remember, the best thing about Hooters, according to our waitress Marie and manager Bob Hall, is “the girls.”
Buffalo Wild Wings
Buffalo Wild Wings, or B-Dubbs, is a fun bar-and-grill concept that caters to families or groups of friends looking to have a good time. With a bar and a full menu ranging from munchies to hearty dinner options, this is a great place to watch your favorite game or match wits with other patrons playing on the Buzztime® Trivia system offered each night. The closest B-Dubbs to campus is at 1123 N. Water St.
We were impressed by the variety of 14 sauces, ranging from sweet to screaming hot. With so many sauces, Buffalo Wild Wings is sure to cover the tastes of everyone in the party. The wings are a good size and very saucy, and not too small for the value. After sampling the Medium, Honey BBQ, Spicy Garlic, and Asian Zing (with the last two being recommended by our waitress Kristin), the clubhouse favorite was by far the Asian Zing with its interesting combination of chili peppers, soy sauce and ginger mixed with a little sweetness.
The menu offered a great variety of munchie foods, including mini corn dogs, nachos, wraps and ribs. The most interesting thing, however, was that if you really enjoyed one of their sauces, you could purchase a bottle to take home with your leftovers. B-Dubbs rates high in flavor, variety of wings and fun, but only if you like places that are really loud and a little smoky.
WOW
The New Orleans-inspired World of Wings (WOW) Café and Wingery at 2116 N. Farwell Ave. (one block south of the Oriental Theatre) was ultimately our favorite place on our hunt for buffalo wings outside the immediate area. With its wide open space, a pool table, dart boards, HDTVs and a full bar, it looks like a high-ceilinged restaurant that the owner molded into a fun local hangout for the neighborhood crowd.
With 17 varieties of wings, WOW provided the greatest variety for the value, ranging from the standard buffalo flavors to exotic ones. The best feature of these wings is their size, as WOW doesn’t skimp on their portions. And the wings are fresh, not frozen. While their original buffalo wing is pretty standard (not too spicy but a little bit of tease), WOW’s originality is featured in their Kansas City Honey BBQ, which is a good “two parts honey, one part BBQ,” and the Texas Mesquite BBQ, which tastes good enough to make you like Texas, but not enough to make you a Cowboys fan. The Thai Peanut, which was recommended by our waitress Emily, was another favorite with its mellow taste of barbecue and peanuts blended together and topped with crushed peanuts. Despite its many competitors, it was the unique, tangy flavor of the Jamaican Jerk that was voted the clubhouse favorite.
The size, flavor and value of the wings alone could have made WOW the clear Warrior favorite, but their most interesting menu item won us over. WOW lets you order a whopping 1,000 pieces of chicken wings (over ten times more than their competitors) for the low price of $399! This is definitely the place to try for any buffalo wing connoisseur.
Conway’s
If you are looking for something a little closer to home, try Conway’s at 2127 W. Wells St. Known for its live bands, Jazz night and cozy space, the chicken wings here were unlike any other, as they were expertly smoked using applewood chips by the chef, Gary. Although Conway’s only offers two varieties of wings—barbeque or spicy—both stand up well to the smoky flavor and are just as large as the portions at WOW. They also offer a special on Monday nights where you can get wings for just 35 cents! While the other college hangouts are pretty crowded most nights, Conway’s offers a laid-back atmosphere to enjoy the many musical offerings and food-and-drink specials. Plus, where else can you enjoy your wings in the company of Jake and Elwood Blues? Conway’s rates high in the flavor and atmosphere, and they are easily accessible by L.I.M.O., which is clearly an added bonus.
All in all, the Warriors had a successful buffalo wing hunt and are looking forward to their next journey into the wild world of college food (but only after a very long nap.
Popularity: 10% [?]